yes my phrasing is a tad off. im not only wanting but willing to start over. as i would love to be there from the beginning. i never got that feeling on live. and i never got it here. and i really dont know if i will get it in any game. unless the game was to do a character wipe to start over.
I have found that starting over in the same game does NOT give you "that feeling." When I first logged onto EQlive, I was amazed, probably more so than most because of my lack of knowledge about computers and the internet. At that time, everything to me was totally unbelievable and astonishing. Unfortunately, I started maybe a month or so before Luclin came out and once I had Luclin and PoP, "that feeling" left pretty quickly. I went from being amazed at how much there was to explore in just Misty Thicket alone, to being bored because now I could look around just about any zone with just a click of the mouse or a short wait by the scion.
When I first started SoD, about a year ago, "that feeling" came back to me again. I was like wow, I know this stuff, but yet I don't know this stuff. I couldn't seem to spend enough time trying to take in as much of the new as I could. However, "that feeling" fades once you know most of the content and zones and mobs and you become one of the folks that can easily answer most of the questions asked in /ooc.
After playing EQlive for about 2 years, I became totally bored. So, I thought what you thought, I'd start all over again from scratch, I made another account so that I couldn't even use shared bank from my original account. "That feeling" never came back, having known all the newb quests and what mobs drop what just made it just as boring if not more so than being level 65. And EQlive is worse because of the adding of so many expansions. Sure I knew all the low end content really well, but the high end content was a bit more difficult to learn because you no sooner start exploring/learning it and bam, a new expansion and trying to get a group in an old expansion zone is next to never. And of course exploring solo in high end is near impossible, especially for a cleric.
SoD no longer gives me "that feeling" either, however SoD also still has folks needing to explore, SoD still has places unseen and that are not just a mouse click away. And what's nice is there is still a chance of finding others to explore with because there isn't yet another expansion for high ends to abandon what they currently have leaving the up and coming high ends out of the exploration fun. Also, I enjoy starting new characters over again on SoD. I don't get "that feeling" but I do have fun because the quests and content is different in every starting zone. So, I purposely start new characters of varying races just so I can experience quests and content for that race/class combo.
So no, starting over on any game will never give you "that feeling" back, but the addition of new things to content that already exists makes you stick around to enjoy that fun. Much better than adding an expansion and making the game "stupid easy" in the sense that it's boring(PoP). Or adding an expansion and making what you had already, obsolete.