Maiandra and I spend quite a bit of time questing with our various characters, and lately we keep bumping into quest NPC's who will give the quest, the items you need to start the quest (if any), but refuse to accept the turn-in items. Message says "<NPC> has returned <item(s)> to you". We felt it would be most useful to make one thread in which other people could add NPC's with the same issue.
Farmer Nolan (Western Badlands, Antique Plate quest)
Ullra (13 Froglok warrior) has killed both Borstick and Neverik, but farmer Nolan keeps returning their amulets. Have not tried handing them in separately yet.
Ylva McMarren (Halas, quest for Ylva's stew)
Really odd here: Maiandra and Taffimai did this quest together (dialogue and turn-in), but Maiandra (48 Wood Elf druid) got the reward, whereas Taffimai (48 Dark Elf rogue) was unable to hand in the necklace. Both characters found their necklace before doing the dialogue.
Greta McDerrick (Halas, Shaman newbie quest)
Ytze (14 Froglok shaman) did the dialogue, was told to find Ice Poppies, found them, but can't hand them in.
On a sidenote, I thought I had the same problem with an NPC in the newport rogue guild (Pick Lock quest), but here I discovered why: as this quest was implemented after Taffimai had already trivialled the doors, I had picked them all and tried to hand in all three playing cards at once. Giving them one by one in the correct order got me my rewards. Just goes to show that not every stubborn NPC is broken
Farmer Nolan (Western Badlands, Antique Plate quest)
Ullra (13 Froglok warrior) has killed both Borstick and Neverik, but farmer Nolan keeps returning their amulets. Have not tried handing them in separately yet.
Ylva McMarren (Halas, quest for Ylva's stew)
Really odd here: Maiandra and Taffimai did this quest together (dialogue and turn-in), but Maiandra (48 Wood Elf druid) got the reward, whereas Taffimai (48 Dark Elf rogue) was unable to hand in the necklace. Both characters found their necklace before doing the dialogue.
Greta McDerrick (Halas, Shaman newbie quest)
Ytze (14 Froglok shaman) did the dialogue, was told to find Ice Poppies, found them, but can't hand them in.
On a sidenote, I thought I had the same problem with an NPC in the newport rogue guild (Pick Lock quest), but here I discovered why: as this quest was implemented after Taffimai had already trivialled the doors, I had picked them all and tried to hand in all three playing cards at once. Giving them one by one in the correct order got me my rewards. Just goes to show that not every stubborn NPC is broken